Two Questions, Two Pathways

When a new owner asks me which structure to choose, I start with two questions, in this order.

First, what is the business for, and who is in it? Will you work alone or with partners? Does the work carry real risk to clients, property or employees? Do you plan to bring in investors, or keep it small? The answers point to the legal structure: how the business is set up with your state and how well it separates your personal assets from the business.

Second, how will the profit be taxed? Once the structure fits the business, the next question is how the IRS taxes what it earns and how you will pay yourself. Some of these are choices you make with the IRS after the business exists, not structures you form with the state.

Answer them in that order. Choosing a structure for a tax result before you know what the business needs usually means changing it later.

The common structures

Sole proprietorship. This is the starting point, not a filing. If you work for yourself and haven't formed anything, you are a sole proprietor. You and the business are the same person in the eyes of the law and the IRS. Profit goes on your personal return, and business debts are your debts.

General partnership. Two or more people running a business together for profit can be a partnership without filing anything with the state. That surprises many owners. Each partner can usually bind the partnership, and each is personally responsible for the partnership's debts, including ones another partner created. The partnership files its own information return (Form 1065), but it doesn't pay income tax itself. Each partner's share of the profit passes to them on a Schedule K-1.

Limited liability partnership (LLP). An LLP is a partnership that has registered with the state for liability protection. Generally, a partner isn't personally responsible for another partner's mistakes or misconduct, but remains responsible for their own. LLPs are common among professional firms such as accountants, attorneys and architects. Who may form one, and how far the protection reaches, varies by state. For taxes, an LLP is usually treated as a partnership.

Limited liability company (LLC). An LLC is formed under state law and gives its owners (called members) liability protection, much like a corporation, with fewer formalities. Its tax treatment is flexible:

  • One owner: by default, the IRS treats it as a "disregarded entity." Profit goes on the owner's personal return, much like a sole proprietorship.
  • Two or more owners: by default, it is taxed as a partnership.
  • Either one: it can elect to be taxed as a corporation (Form 8832) or, if it qualifies, as an S Corp (Form 2553).

C corporation. A corporation is a separate legal person owned by shareholders. It has the clearest separation between the owners and the business, and it is what most outside investors expect. A C corporation pays its own federal income tax on profit. When it pays that profit out to shareholders as dividends, the shareholders pay tax again. This is often called double taxation.

S corporation. An S Corp is a federal tax election, not a separate type of business. A corporation or an LLC that qualifies files Form 2553, signed by all shareholders. Profit then passes through to the owners' personal returns instead of being taxed at the company level. To qualify, the company generally must:

  • be a domestic corporation, or an LLC taxed as one
  • have no more than 100 shareholders
  • have only individuals, certain trusts and estates as shareholders (no partnerships, corporations or nonresident aliens)
  • have only one class of stock

Why would an owner choose this election, and what does the IRS mean by a "reasonable salary"? That gets its own section below.

Side by side

StructureFormed byOwners' personal liabilityHow profit is taxed (default)Federal returnOften fits
Sole proprietorshipNothing to fileUnlimitedOwner's personal return; self-employment tax on all profitSchedule C on Form 1040One person testing an idea or running a low-risk service
General partnershipAn agreement, written or notUnlimited, including for other partners' actionsPasses through to partnersForm 1065 + K-1sRarely the best choice; many partnerships exist by accident
LLPRegistration with the stateGenerally protected from other partners' actions; still liable for your ownPasses through to partnersForm 1065 + K-1sLicensed professional firms with several partners
LLC, one ownerArticles of organizationGenerally protectedOwner's personal return, unless it elects otherwiseSchedule C on Form 1040Most solo owners who want protection without heavy paperwork
LLC, two or more ownersArticles of organizationGenerally protectedPasses through as a partnership, unless it elects otherwiseForm 1065 + K-1sCo-owned small businesses
C corporationArticles of incorporationGenerally protectedCompany pays its own tax; shareholders pay again on dividendsForm 1120Businesses raising outside investment or planning to keep profit in the company
S Corp election (corporation or LLC)Form 2553 with the IRSSame as the underlying entityPasses through; working owners take a reasonable salary through payrollForm 1120-S + K-1sProfitable businesses where payroll-tax savings outweigh the added cost

Liability protection is never absolute. Mixing personal and business money, skipping required filings or signing personal guarantees can weaken it.

Before you elect S Corp status

I see a lot of advice on social media telling business owners to elect S Corp status. It can save real money, but there is a catch: it only pays off under the right conditions, and it comes with new obligations. Before you elect, make sure it fits your situation and know what to expect.

The savings come from payroll taxes. In a sole proprietorship or an LLC taxed by default, the owner pays self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare, 15.3% up to the annual wage cap) on nearly all of the profit. In an S Corp, the owner who works in the business is an employee. Payroll taxes apply to the salary, but not to profit taken out as a distribution.

A simplified example

Say your business earns $120,000 in profit before paying you. These figures are rounded, cover payroll taxes only, and leave out income tax.

LLC taxed by defaultSame LLC with an S Corp election
Your payAll $120,000 is self-employment income$70,000 salary through payroll, $50,000 distribution
Social Security and MedicareAbout $16,955About $10,710, on the salary only
DifferenceAbout $6,245 less

That difference is before the S Corp's added costs: a payroll service, quarterly and year-end payroll filings, state unemployment insurance, and a separate business tax return (Form 1120-S). At lower profit, those costs can take most or all of the savings. That's why the timing of the election matters as much as the election itself.

What "reasonable salary" means

The IRS requires an S Corp to pay reasonable compensation to an owner who works in the business before taking distributions. There is no set percentage. The question is what the business would have to pay someone else to do the work you do.

In its guidance, the IRS lists factors courts consider, including:

  • your training and experience
  • your duties and responsibilities
  • the time and effort you put into the business
  • what the business pays employees who aren't owners
  • what comparable businesses pay for similar services
  • the timing and manner of bonuses to key people
  • any compensation agreements, and whether a formula is used to set pay

The IRS can reclassify distributions as wages when the salary is too low, which brings back the payroll taxes plus penalties and interest. A salary of $0, or a token salary while the owner takes large distributions, is the pattern that draws attention.

Two details owners often miss

  • Health insurance. For an owner with more than 2% of the company, the S Corp pays or reimburses the premiums and reports them as wages on the owner's W-2. They are not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax, and the owner may be able to deduct them on their personal return. The rules are specific, so set this up before the year starts.
  • Documentation. Keep a short written record of how you set your salary: your role, your hours, and what similar positions pay. Review it each year as the business changes.

The S Corp election is filed on Form 2553, signed by all shareholders. To take effect for the current tax year, it generally must be filed within 2 months and 15 days after the year begins.

Going into business with someone else

When two or more people own a business together, the structure and the agreements behind it matter even more. These are the problems I see most often.

  1. The accidental partnership. Two friends start working together, split the money and never file anything. They are a general partnership, with each personally on the hook for the other's decisions.
  2. No written agreement. Whatever the structure, co-owners need a written agreement. It should cover who puts in what, how profit is split, who decides what, and what happens if someone leaves, dies or wants out.
  3. Assuming an LLP protects you from everything. It generally protects you from your partners' mistakes, not your own.
  4. Electing S Corp status with an ineligible owner. A partnership, a corporation or a nonresident alien as a shareholder can disqualify the election.
  5. Splitting profit one way on paper and another in practice. If the agreement says 50/50 but the money moves differently, the records and the tax returns stop matching.

Filing with your state

Business entities are formed at the state level, so the filing office, the fees and the yearly requirements depend on where you form the business and where it operates. In most states, filings go through the Secretary of State. If you form in one state but do business in another, you may also need to register in the second state. Always check the official state website before you file.

In Maryland, where Montgomery Advisory is based, the State Department of Assessments and Taxation (SDAT) handles formation. According to its fee schedule, the base filing fee is $100 to:

  • form an LLC (articles of organization)
  • form a stock corporation (articles of incorporation, when the total par value of its stock is $100,000 or less)
  • register an LLP

Expedited service adds $50. A general partnership isn't on that schedule; it can exist without a state filing.

Maryland also requires entities registered with SDAT to file an annual report each year. Check SDAT for the current deadline and fee before you file.

Whatever you choose, the records are the same from day one: a separate business bank account, a copy of your formation documents and your owners' agreement, your EIN letter, and books kept current every month.

Where to start

Before you file anything, answer three questions in writing: how many owners there will be, how much liability risk the work carries, and how much profit you realistically expect in the next two years. Those answers narrow the choice quickly.

We help owners work through the financial and tax side of this decision and set up clean records from the first day. Forming the entity, drafting an operating or partnership agreement, and questions about how much liability protection you have belong with a licensed attorney, and we're glad to work alongside yours. Schedule a consultation, and we will break down the business terminology so you are set up for success.

Sources