Why boards ask for a checklist
Board members carry real responsibility for a nonprofit's money, but most aren't accountants. They're volunteers with full-time jobs who meet a few times a year. They don't need a lecture on internal controls. They need a short list of questions they can ask, and a clear sense of what a good answer sounds like.
That's what this is. Go through it at your next board or finance committee meeting. Every "no" or "I'm not sure" is worth a follow-up conversation.
The checklist
Cash coming in
- Two people are present when cash or checks from events and collections are counted, and both sign the count sheet.
- Donations are deposited within a set number of days, and the person who records them is not the only person who handles them.
- Someone compares donor acknowledgment letters against recorded deposits at least quarterly.
Cash going out
- Payments above a set dollar amount need a second approval, and that amount is written in a board-approved policy.
- No one approves their own reimbursement, including the executive director.
- Only one designated person can add a new vendor or change a vendor's bank details, and changes are confirmed by phone.
- Organization credit cards have limits, and every statement is reviewed by someone other than the cardholder.
Bank and records
- Bank accounts are reconciled every month, and a second person reviews and initials the reconciliation.
- At least one board officer can view the bank account online.
- Former staff and volunteers lose access to bank and accounting systems the day they leave.
Grants and restricted funds
- A log lists every restricted gift or grant, its purpose, its deadline and its reporting dates.
- Expenses are coded to the grant that pays for them, so a report can be run for each funder.
- The board sees unrestricted cash separately from the total bank balance.
Payroll
- Someone other than the payroll preparer reviews each payroll register before it's paid.
- New hires and pay changes require written approval.
Board oversight
- The board or finance committee receives financial statements at least quarterly, in a format members understand.
- The board reviews the Form 990 before it's filed.
- A conflict-of-interest policy exists, and board members sign it every year.
- A whistleblower policy tells staff and volunteers how to raise a concern safely.
- Financial policies were reviewed by the board within the last two years.
What I see go wrong
The weak point in most small nonprofits isn't a missing policy. It's that one capable, trusted person does almost everything financial, and the board signs off without really looking. That arrangement works until the person leaves, gets sick or makes a mistake no one is positioned to catch.
The fix is not to distrust that person. It's to add a few points where someone else looks: a second set of eyes on the bank reconciliation, a board officer with read-only bank access, a second approval on large payments. Those checks protect the organization, and they protect the person doing the work.
Where to start
Don't try to fix every "no" at once. Pick the two items that would worry you most if something went wrong, and put them on the next board agenda.
If your board would like an independent review of how money moves through your organization, that's work we do for nonprofits. Schedule a consultation, and we'll tell you honestly what we see.
